Each buyer guide starts with a test-pool selection. We list every brand-and-model combination available in the SE Queensland trade market in the relevant category, and we shortlist on three criteria: dealer presence within Brisbane (mandatory), spec sheet relevance to trade application (must), and price tier coverage (we want at least two products per major price tier).
The shortlist gets cross-checked against operator survey responses asking what they would actually consider buying. Anything not on at least three operator shortlists is dropped. The final test pool is typically eight to fourteen units across four to seven brands.
Test units are placed with operators in our trade pool for 8 to 12 weeks at a time. Operators are paired with units that match their normal job profile. We do not place a 5 tonne excavator with an operator who normally runs 1.7 tonne. The point is to find out how the unit performs in the conditions it would be used by a buyer.
During the placement period, every unit gets a weekly scorecard from the operator and a fortnightly site visit from one of our field testers. We measure six to ten dimensions per category: cut quality, jam rate, fuel use, wear pattern, operator comfort, dealer interaction, downtime hours, and so on. The exact scorecard depends on the category.
Anything operators flag mid-test as a deal-breaker is recorded with photos and time stamps. Failure modes get tracked back to root cause where we can. Our field testers do their own service work where possible to reduce dependency on dealer accounts of what failed.
If we did not see
the unit work or fail
with our own eyes,
we did not write it.
// Steelworks Machinery testing policy // since 2009
Each operator returns a weekly score for every dimension. Scores are normalised against the operator's own baseline (some operators rate harshly, some softly) and then aggregated across the placement period. The aggregated scores produce the satisfaction matrix that drives the buyer guide.
We also collect free-form feedback. Often the most important findings come from a single operator's note in the comments box, not the score columns.
Once the test cycle is complete and the scorecards are aggregated, we write the public buyer guide and the private brand-and-model recommendation matrix. The public guide is published on this site. The matrix is held for trade-verified buyers and released on request via the contact form.
We do not name brands publicly because dealer quality varies geographically and a recommendation that holds in Brisbane might not hold in Toowoomba. The matrix is built around what is actually available and supported in your specific market, not what the brand HQ wants you to think.
Six categories live, four more in test cycle for 2026. Browse the catalogue or send a trade enquiry to talk through what kit we would recommend in your market.
Browse buyer guides Trade enquiry →